Chinese Judiciary Seeks to Divert Administrative Cases Out of Litigation

Chinese judicial authorities are making a major push to increase the use of alternative methods to resolve administrative litigation cases. In part, this is an effort to improve mechanisms for resolving citizen grievances. But it is also specifically aimed at channeling cases involving sensitive issues affecting large numbers of aggrieved plaintiffs, such as land seizures, out of the courtroom.

Xiao Yang, president of the Supreme People’s Court, broadly noted the need to improve China’s administrative tribunals in a March 29 speech.  Xiao noted a range of problems with the work of China’s administrative tribunals, including outside interference in court decisions.  He called for a broad range of reforms to address these problems, such as allowing jurisdiction over a particular case to be shifted from a tribunal in one locale to another.

Xiao also specifically noted the need to adopt new mechanisms to handle administrative litigation disputes, particularly those involving "mass administrative disputes" such as land seizures.  He also called for judicial authorities to issue a judicial interpretation on the use of mediation (hejie) in administrative litigation proceedings.

Xiao stated:

Administrative disputes are contradictions among the masses.  The reasons that produce them are complex.  The situation of each administrative case is different.  As a result, the resolution of administrative disputes must use multiple different methods and means . . .

Under the prerequisites of establishing the facts, determining right and wrong, and not harming the national, public, or any other legal interests, we must recommend that administrative organs alter their administrative behavior, compensate the losses of  individuals injured by administrative action, and courts may decide to allow the individual affected by administrative action to withdraw his lawsuit. Particularly as to hotly disputed issues in society that raise mass administrative disputes, such as rural land seizures, urban demolitions, enterprise reform plans, labor and social security cases, and resource and environmental protection cases, it is particularly important to adopt coordinated means of [government action] (xietiao) to the greatest extent possible to handle them.

This requires administrative trial judges to both be skilled at judicial review of cases, and also have strong abilities to negotiate and coordinate, and to conduct work with the masses.  They must both protect the rights of the masses according to law, and also be good at leading parties to correctly and legally exercise their rights.  They must both ensure justice in individual cases, and also pay attention to maximizing the benefit to society.  They must both perform the duties of their job to their fullest ability possible, and also be good at obtaining the support of and relying on local Party committees and governments.  We must prevent and avoid disputes intensifying and changing in form because of errors in work.  We must firmly and promptly issue a judicial interpretation on the issue of coordination (xietiao) and mediation (hejie) in administrative litigation, in order to provide an effective basis for appropriately handling administrative disputes.

Chinese courts have moved to implement Xiao's call.  The Shanghai High People’s Court (HPC) has issued an opinion regarding the use of mediation in administrative litigation, according to an April 8 post on the China Court website.  Zhang Haitang, vice-president of the Shanghai HPC, noted that not all "legally correct" decisions are "reasonable" or "acceptable," and that the legal basis for the Shanghai opinion lies in article 51 of the administrative litigation law, which permits a court to authorize a plaintiff to voluntarily withdraw a lawsuit if the defendant alters the administrative action being challenged.

Increased use of alternative dispute resolution can be a very good thing.  Indeed, the excessive reliance on litigation as the means of choice to resolve citizen grievances has a range of negative consequences in other legal systems, such as that of the United States.  These include increased costs to parties and an inability to fashion flexible solutions acceptable to both sides.  Mediation can offer an alternative means to resolve some of these problems.

But the above calls for the adoption of meditation raise questions.  First, article 50 of China's Administrative Litigation Law (ALL) explicitly bans the use of mediation (tiaojie).  So, as a practical matter, it's unclear whether the Shanghai HPC opinion and Xiao's call for coordination (xietiao) and mediation (hejie) are simply circumventing the ALL's explicit ban on mediation.

Second, the emphasis on mediation in administrative cases is odd as a practical matter.  These are the cases in which the discrepancy in power between plaintiff and defendant is most pronounced, and in which a mediated outcome is most likely to skew the end result to the stronger party.  These are also the cases in which judicial authorities themselves are likely to face the strongest pressure from outside forces such as local Party or government authorities.  In short, these are the cases where the need for plaintiffs (and judges) to rely on clear legal norms, rather than backroom discussions, to protect their rights and guide their decisions is most pronounced.  In fact, this is the reason article 50 of the ALL bans the use of judicial mediation in these cases. 

Third, the particular emphasis on handling "hotly disputed issues in society that raise mass administrative disputes, such as rural land seizures" through mediation is problematic.  These would actually seem less amenable to mediation than, say, disputes between two individual parties with an ongoing relationship, such as marital or labor disputes, where both sides are invested in reaching a mutually acceptable agreement.  But Chinese authorities appear focused on directing collective and sensitive disputes toward mediation channels.  And this isn't just the case for administrative disputes.  On March 7, the Supreme People’s Court issued a circular emphasizing the need for mediation in civil disputes, particularly singling out disputes involving "large numbers of people with shared interests" and those that "are very sensitive, receiving significant social attention."

One possible explanation: Chinese judicial authorities may be uncomfortable with the use of the Chinese court system by legal activists to pursue high-profile cases over the past couple years.  Diverting to mediation those administrative and civil cases that pose direct challenges to government interests, or that have the potential to erupt into mass incidents, might be a way to keep them out of litigation, and possibly out of the public eye.  But without adherence to principles of voluntary settlements on the part of plaintiffs, neutrality on the part of judicial officials conducting the mediation, and ultimate resort to an independent judicial decision on the legal merits should the mediation fail, these measures run the risk of sacrificing the legal interests of plaintiffs.

Comments

[Asia Business Intelligence]

Carl, this confused me somewhat, as I'm of the understanding that the PRC has historically made extensive use of mediation, as opposed to the legal system, for the resolution of disputes. Your explanation is certainly viable, but could it not simply be the case that officials wish to divert cases away from the formal forum, where it may be overwhelmed, to the informal, where they also have the greatest experience dealing with the largest numbers of disputes?

Sincerely,

Rich Kuslan

[Carl Minzner]

Rich,

You're definitely right that mediation has a long tradition in China. And Chinese officials are also certainly interested in using any channels possible to resolve citizen grievances. So it's not surprising that Chinese judicial officials would issue a directive supporting the use of mediation.

But the focus on steering "mass" cases and those that are particularly sensitive is interesting. Certainly, if judicial overload was the main concern, you could imagine a directive stating that mediation is particularly appropriate for family and small claims cases, and that the "mass" cases and sensitive ones should be left to the courtroom. But the decision actually singles out those cases as the ones that should be shifted to mediation. It leaves me asking - why those? Particularly when those are the ones that seem (to me at least) least amenable to resolution through mediation, at least from the perspective of the plaintiff.

Carl

[bhattathiri]

Your website is beautiful, informative and Excellent.
Article by M.P. Bhattathiri, Retired Chief Technical Examiner , to The Govt. of Kerala. Humble request that it may be published in your website and magazine after editing if necessary


In the storm of life we struggle through myriads of stimuli of pressure, stress, and muti-problems that seek for a solution and answer. We are so suppressed by the routine of this every life style that most of us seem helpless. However, if we look closely to ancient techniques we shall discover the magnificent way to understand and realize the ones around us and mostly ourselves. If only we could stop for a moment and allow this to happen. May all beings be happy (Loka Samastha Sukhino Bhavanthu)

Let me bow to Indian Maharishi Patanjali with folded hands who helped in removing the impurities of the mind through his writings on Yoga, impurities of speech through his writings on grammar, and impurities of body through his writings on Ayurveda.
The American justice Dept. have recently approved the power of yoga and meditation vide a recent judgement in the American court." Man Who Slapped Wife Sentenced to Yoga, It's Anger Management, Says Judge." First there was house arrest. Now there's yoga. A judge ordered a man convicted of slapping his wife to take a yoga class as part of his one-year probation. "It's part of anger management," County Criminal Court at Law Judge Larry Standley said of the ancient Hindu philosophy of exercise and well-being. "For people who are into it, it really calms them down. " Standley, a former prosecutor, said the case of James Lee Cross was unique. Cross, a 53-year-old car salesman from Tomball, explained that his wife was struggling with a substance abuse problem and that he struck her on New Year's Eve during an argument about her drinking. "He was trying to get a hold of her because she has a problem," Standley said after the court hearing. "I thought this would help him realize that he only has control over himself." The sentence came as a surprise to Cross, who was told to enroll in a class and report back to Standley on his progress. "I'm not very familiar with it," Cross said of yoga. "From what I understand, it may help in a couple ways, not only as far as mentally settling, but maybe a little weight loss." Darla Magee, an instructor at Yoga Body Houston in River Oaks, said she would recommend that Cross take a basic yoga class emphasizing breathing and including a variety of postures -- forward bends, back bends and twists. "Yoga can help us to get rid of many emotional issues we might have," she said. "It's a spiritual cleanse." Prosecutor Lincoln Goodwin agreed to a sentence of probation without jail time because Cross had no significant criminal history http://www.chron.com/cs/CDA/ssistory.mpl/metropolitan/2365341.
Yoga is far from simply being physical exercises, rather it is an aid to establishing a new
way of life which embraces both inner and outer realities.However this way of life is an
experience which cannot be understood intellectually and will only become living knowledge through practice and experience. Yoga which is one of the greatest Indian contribution to the world has got vast potential in all fields. and an Indian way to get synergy among body, mind and soul.
In Tihar jail India Yoga is experimented among the inmates and found successful. Their criminal mentality is changed. This study aimed at investigating the effect of Vipassana Meditation (VM) on Quality of Life (QOL), Subjective Well-Being (SWB), and Criminal Propensity (CP) among inmates of Tihar Jail,
Delhi. To this effect the following hypotheses were formulated. 1. There will be a significant positive effect of VM on the QOL of inmates of Tihar jail. 2. VM will have a positive and significant effect on SWB of inmates. 3. Criminal propensity (CP) of inmates will decrease significantly after attending the VM course. 4. There will be significant difference in SWB and CP of experimental (Vipassana) group and control (non-Vipassana) group. 5. Male and female inmates will differ significantly in SWB and CP, as a result of VM. In the famous "Time" magazine the importance meditation and yoga, an ancient Indian system, is high-lighted that the ancient mind- and spirit-enhancing art is becoming increasingly popular and gaining medical legitimacy. It is a multi billion dollar business in US. In many Universities it is accepted as subject and included in the Syllabus. In the latest famous book "Inspire! What Great Leaders Do" written by Mr.Lance Secretan recently published by John Wiley and sons, the benefit of meditation is elaborately described for good corporate governance. By practicing transcendental meditation, or TM, many people have got relief from back pain, neck pain, depression. The mind calms and quiets, . What thoughts you have during meditation become clearer, more focused. Anger, anxiety and worries give way to a peace. In the world exorbitant medical expenses one can definitely make use of meditation. Maharshi Mahesh Yogi and Sri Ravi Sankar are popularizing this. The Iyengar Yoga institute in US is famous. Food habits should be to keep mind and body in pace. one can get more than enough protein and other essential nutrients by eating a balanced vegetarian diet of fruits, vegetables, grains, legumes, dairy products, nuts and seeds. A vegan diet (without dairy products) is also adequate, as long as you eat enough protein-rich wholegrains, legumes, nuts and seeds. In any case, your body will "tell" you what you need to eat. If you have a particular craving for any type of food, it may mean that you need the nutrients that it supplies – so trust the natural signals your body gives you .
In Bhagavad-Gita Gita Lord Krishna has inspired Arjuna to rise from his depression by preaching Gita in the battlefield and to rise from the depression to do his duties. In Holy Gita we can see, being hidden by the cosmic overview of any institution beset with myriad problems, not the least of which is its lack of moral probity, there is a groundswell of educated people seeking answers to deeply personal but universally asked questions. Chie Executives taking lessons from yoga, meditation and learning how to deal with human resources equations in an enlightened manner. Individuals from every walk of life can get ideas of how to be better human beings, more balanced and less stressed out.
Medical studies continue to show regular meditation working magic in reducing blood pressure and stress-related illnesses, including heart disease. Brain images show that regular meditation helps calm the most active sensory-assaulted parts of the brain. The ancient Hindu sage Patanjali who had mastered the secrets of the human mind has written a book "Yogasutra".In this book we can see how super powers can be achieved by meditation. It has both cosmic relevance and cosmic resonance. In spite of its universal appeal, for most people total control of mind remains an elusive goal and daunting task. From time immemorial, there have been many attempts throughout the world to unlock the mysteries of the mind and to achieve total control over it through a variety of techniques. One of the most powerful of these techniques is meditation.
Many spiritual leaders, sages, saints, and holy people such asSri. Buddha, Sri Ramakrishna, Madam Sarada Devi, and Swami Vivekananda have practiced this. One of the ways to control physiological reactions to psychological stimuli is meditation, Yoga, Zen Buddhism etc. The scientists take Transcendental Meditation (TM) as the uniform technique, and base their observations on the study of the subjects engaged in this form of meditation. In summing up the results the scientists have come to conclusion that the effect of meditation is a "wakeful, hypo-metabolic state". They have found that: 1) Yogis could slow both heart rate and rate of respiration, 2) Yogis could slow the rate of metabolism as confirmed by decreased oxygen consumption and carbon-die-oxide output. 3) Electro-Encephala-Gram (EEG - recording of brain activity) in Yogis showed changes of calmness in the form of "alpha rhythm" during both eyes closed and eyes open recordings. 4) Their skin resistance to electric stimulation was increased (indicating increased tolerance to external stimuli). Our usual 'defense-alarm' reaction to emotional and physical stress is in the form of "fright, flight, and fight" mediated through over-secretion of certain neuron-transmitters and neuron-modulators, namely adrenaline and dopamine by way of stimulation of sympathetic nervous system. Under the influence of these chemicals and hormones, we reflexively become panicky or aggressive, our blood pressure rises. Thus stress and anxiety is the end result if we allow our natural age-old sympathetic reactions to act and to come to surface. We try to run away, become fearful, or fight the situation. But today these 'defense-alarm' reactions have no place in our lives. Rather, they should be replaced by more calm and serene reactions of equanimity and fearlessness. The need is to just 'face the brute, and it will go away'. Such desirable reactions of non-aggression and peaceful attitude are generated by Y ga and meditation. EEG Studies on Yogis and The Zen Meditations: Yogis practicing Raja-Yoga claim that during the state of Samadhi they are oblivious to the internal and external stimuli, and they enjoy a calm ecstasy during that state. A study was undertaken to record the electrical activity of their brain during this state by means of a regular and useful test known as electroencephalography EEG. Physiological and experimental studies have demonstrated that the basis of conscious state of brain, among other things, is due to activation of "reticular system" in the brain-stem in response to internal and external stimuli. These stimuli bring about various changes during sleeping and wakeful states of the organism and these can be studied by EEG. The study was carried out on four subjects during the state of concentration and meditation. Effects of external stimuli, like a loud gong, strong light, thermal simulation, and vibrations were studied. The results were compiled and analyzed. It was observed that two Yogis could keep their hands immersed in extremely cold water for about 50 minutes (raised pain threshold). During the state of meditation, all of them showed persistent "alpha activity" in their EEG with increased amplitude wave pattern, both during 'eyes closed' and 'eyes open' recording. It was observed that these alpha activities could not be blocked by various sensory stimuli during meditation. It was also observed that those, who had well-marked "alpha activity" in their resting EEG showed greater aptitude and zeal for maintaining the practice of Yoga. Similar observations and results were obtained when EEGs were recorded in persons adept in Zen Meditative technique. Can we say that only those persons who exhibit such recording of "alpha wave rhythm" in their EEG are fit for Yoga? and be designated as right candidates for meditation and Yoga practices? (Such experiments are indeed very few and the number of yogis examined is also very small. Therefore, scientifically and statistically these observations have only a tentative importance. Further research is definitely called for, albeit it will have its own limitations.) It is said that in the unknown period of Lord Jesus Christ , He was under meditation.
Ref. Yoga magazines
Newsweek.com
New York times
Time magazine